Posted October 21, 2013

Heisman Watch Week 8: Jameis Winston makes his case in blowout of Clemson

Clemson Tigers, Florida State Seminoles, Heisman, Heisman Trophy, Heisman Watch, Johnny Football, Johnny Manziel, Tajh Boyd
Jameis Winston handled the pressure of Death Valley. Now can he handle Heisman hype?

Jameis Winston easily handled the pressure of Death Valley. Now can he handle Heisman hype? (Mike Stewart/AP)

In the end, the epic ACC clash between Florida State and Clemson did exactly what many expected for college football’s Heisman race: One quarterback saw his stock rise sky-high, while the other saw his plummet.

But few expected Jameis Winston and the visiting Seminoles to be as explosive as they were in Saturday’s 51-14 beatdown of the Tigers. A game that had been billed as Winston’s first true test turned out to not be much of a test at all. The redshirt freshman repeatedly picked apart Clemson’s defense in front of a stunned crowd at Death Valley. Tigers quarterback Tajh Boyd, on the other hand, often appeared befuddled in the pocket, a stunning contrast to the senior’s normally poised demeanor.

Thanks to a dominant performance, Winston jumped past Boyd to become the top mover and shaker in our Heisman Watch. We’re not ready, however, to dethrone Oregon quarterback Marcus Mariota from the top spot just yet.

Heisman Watch — Week 8

1. Marcus Mariota, QB Oregon
2. Jameis Winston, QB Florida State
3. Johnny Manziel, QB Texas A&M
4. Bryce Petty, QB Baylor
5. AJ McCarron, QB Alabama
6. Tajh Boyd, QB Clemson
7. Teddy Bridgewater, QB Louisville
8. Aaron Murray, QB Georgia
9. Braxton Miller, QB Ohio State
10. Melvin Gordon, RB Wisconsin

STAPLES: FSU looks like dominant ‘Noles teams of past in Clemson rout

Player of the Week

Jameis Winston, Florida State QB
Week 8 stats: 22-of-34 for 444 yards, three touchdowns, one interception; seven rushes for two yards, one touchdown

Are there any doubters left? Winston’s production in Florida State’s last two games — both expected to be challenges for the ‘Noles — proved that the country has another freshman sensation on its hands. Two weeks after toasting an unbeaten Maryland team in a rout, Winston did the same against No. 3 Clemson in Death Valley in what many billed as the biggest ACC game in regular-season history.

Winston’s first pass of the game went for a touchdown when Kelvin Benjamin hauled in the 22-yard toss, and the quarterback found Rashad Greene for a 72-yard score in the second quarter to help the Seminoles build a stunning 27-7 halftime lead. In all Florida State’s 51 points were the most Clemson ever gave up at home.

Winston’s 444 passing yards were a season-high for the first-year starter, who has now completed 71 percent of his throws for 20 touchdowns and only three picks. He has a chance to replicate Johnny Manziel’s success and become the second freshman to take home the Heisman Trophy. Luckily for Winston, his Seminoles are in great shape in the national title picture. Florida State debuted at No. 2 in the first BCS rankings released Sunday, and the last time the program boasted a 6-0 record (1999), it won the BCS championship.

ELLIS: Florida State debuts at No. 2 in first BCS standings

Stock rising

Marcus Mariota
In terms of ball security, Saturday wasn’t the sophomore quarterback’s best outing. His two fumbles in the first half on Saturday led to two Washington State touchdowns. Nevertheless, the Ducks blasted coach Mike Leach’s Cougars 62-38, and Mariota was responsible for 394 yards of offense (327 passing, 67 rushing) and three touchdowns (two passing, one rushing). He also did not throw an interception, and now has 19 touchdown passes with no picks this season. Most importantly, second-ranked Oregon is still undefeated.

Johnny Manziel
Yes, the Aggies were narrowly upset by spirited Auburn 45-41 in College Station to fall to 5-2, but don’t forget that Texas A&M’s two defeats last season were not enough to prevent Manziel from winning the Heisman Trophy. History doesn’t favor Johnny Football to repeat, but if the sophomore keeps putting up numbers like he did against the Tigers — he threw for 454 yards and four touchdowns, while running for 48 yards and another score — he will remain a serious contender.

RICKMAN: Between The Hashes: Auburn DT trolls Johnny Manziel, Mizzou fans get cocky

Bryce Petty
The junior quarterback for the high-octane Bears has thrown for at least 300 yards and two touchdowns in each of Baylor’s six wins. In a 71-7 whipping of Iowa State on Saturday, Petty throw for 343 and two touchdowns. He finished the weekend as the country’s leader in passing efficiency (221.8) and yards per attempt (14).

Melvin Gordon
He is the lone tailback with a realistic chance of winning this season’s quarterback-heavy Heisman race. In the Badgers’ 56-32 trampling of Illinois on Saturday, the sophomore ran for three scores and 142 yards, and became the second player in the country to reach 1,000 rushing yards this season. Gordon’s Heisman hopes seemed bleak after Ohio State held the tailback to a season-low 74 yards and no touchdowns in a 31-24 Wisconsin loss on Sept. 28, bu in the two games since he has rushed for 314 yards and four touchdowns while averaging more than eight yards per carry.

We've seen Johnny Manziel overcome two Texas A&M losses to win the Heisman before.

Johnny Manziel overcome two losses by Texas A&M last fall to win the Heisman Trophy. (Bob Levey/AP)

Stock falling

Tajh Boyd
The wheels came off for Boyd on Saturday night in the Tigers’ loss to Florida State. Against a stifling Seminoles defense — which had forced a turnover in 10 straight games — the senior tied a season-high with two interceptions. Things really started to go downhill for him late in the first quarter when, with Clemson already trailing 10-0, Florida State defensive end Mario Edwards returned a Boyd fumble 37 yards for a touchdown. Boyd completed only 45.9 percent of his passes and overthrew his receivers a number of times. Prior to Saturday, his least-accurate performance had been in the Tigers’ season-opener against Georgia, when he completed 60 percent of his throws. Unless Winston stumbles along the way and Clemson wins out, Boyd’s shot at winning the Heisman is likely over.

Aaron Murray
It’s easy to feel bad for Murray, who’s Heisman chances have fallen victim to the Bulldogs’ injury-riddled roster, but his performance in a shocking loss to Vanderbilt was not up to the senior’s usual high standards. Murray completed 16-of-28 passes for a season-low 114 yards, the third-lowest output of his career. He rushed for two touchdowns, but he also threw a pick and did not complete a touchdown pass. Regardless of his stats, Georgia has fallen way short of preseason expectations, which is perhaps the biggest knock on Murray’s candidacy.

Heisman chatter

Tweets of the week
That’s pretty sharp for Florida State’s freshman:

The hype surrounds Winston, but the season isn’t over yet:

It was a major slip-up on a big stage for Boyd:

Video of the week
It’s difficult to pick a single moment from Winston’s performance against Clemson, so let’s just enjoy the entire highlight video. Take note of the leadership exhibited by the redshirt freshman in his pregame speech.

MANDEL: College Football Overtime: Upset-heavy Week 8 leaves SEC looking vulnerable; more Overtime



All of the QB's mentioned should be considered for the Heisman; however, no other quaterback has done more for for his team than Manziel.   In the 2 deep depth chart on defense, 17 of the 22 players are Freshmen playing in their first collegiate season and is the main reason A&M doesn't have a defense to stop other teams from scoring.  But still,  opponents have to score 40 or more points to beat the Aggies.

Every week, Manziel goes out to face all challengers with the only help from his offensive line and an emerging super star in Mike Evans.  So far, no one has been able to stop that lethal combination.(If Evans doesn't leave for the NFL, he should be considered next year for the Heisman).

So I wish that you consider how these other Heisman candidate quarter backs would preform in Manziel's position at A&M.  What if Manziel played for Alabama ?  


West coast fans - we don't have to take this biased crap. Stop buying anything advertised on ESPN and SI and support companies that support the Pac 12. Make a play for your team, support companies that support our teams. Sick of the bias. This is the kind of crap that brought us ND vs. Bama last year and a rematch the previous year. 


I think we all know that Johnny Football won't win it this season for many reasons.

But, his QB rating last season when he won was 155.3.  So far this season it's 182.8.

Last yr his completion % was 68.0% and so far this season it's 73.3%

His yards per attempt last yr was 8.8 and it's 10.5 so far this yr.

He is rushing for less yrs and TD's though...

My point is that he is playing as well, if not a bit better than he did last yr and that is getting lost due to his off field antics. 


The ACC should make a video befalling the loss of Boyd's Heisman hopes as well lol


Winston has a windup like Byron Leftwich. He's not as good as his stats look. His team is totally stacked top to bottom.


@JeffBockert FSU is not Notre Dame;after 6 games won by margins averaging  over 30 points the Seminoles have not  needed any luck to win.. The Irish already to this point last season had 3 narrow escapes with 4 more to come. I do not care if we play for the BCS title this ;season but rather that we  continue  to win. Defeating  Miami-Fla ,win the ACC will be enough if we are unbeaten. Best of fortune to the Ducks and the Tide.


@JeffBockert If your teams were smart enough to play all games on our time, you would get the recognition you deserve.

Besides, they still have Mariota No. 1.


@Sportsfan18 I don't see how his off the field antics are playing a factor. When is the last time you heard anyone talk about them? The reason he isn't currently the frontrunner is because there are two other guys--Winston and Mariotta--playing just as well as he is and are on undefeated teams.


@Eric70 You must be seeing no one else can see. Haters will hate.


@Eric70 You must not watch football a lot. This kid has every tool. Great arm, great mobility, great decision making, great leadership skills. And he might be an even better baseball player.